Each seat cross-examines another seat's case. Then each one says whether it holds or changes its vote. In this meeting, no seat changed its vote.
The Go-to-Market Operator questions The Compounder
You say cut the worst campaigns first, judged on whether each ad dollar returns SGD 1.61 in sales. That measures the first order, not the customer. A campaign that looks weak on the first order may be the one bringing in people who come back next month without being paid for again. Cut it and you have dropped your best customers to save on your cheapest sales. So before you cut anything, check which campaigns bring buyers who order again unpaid. On the chain, "walk past" is the wrong call. You have five weeks, and that deadline gives you leverage. Ask them in writing for the listing fee, the stock they need, their margin and the exit terms. If they cannot price it, then walk. Skipping that question means saying no to a deal you never priced.
Holds RESHAPEbecause nothing here shows whether ad-bought customers keep paying, and that is still what decides between cutting and scaling.
The Customer-Obsessed Scaler questions The Compounder
You say a deal you can't price is one to walk past, and that the chain will still want you later. Nobody here knows that. Walking past is the one move that might not reverse. Asking the chain for its fee, its stock order and its margin costs you one email and keeps the door open, so send it this week. Your worst-first cut is right in spirit, but it ranks campaigns by the ad platform's own report. That report claims credit for loyal customers who would have bought anyway. Then you cut the wrong campaigns with confidence. Start from the customer instead: who is new, who is returning, and who comes back without being paid for. Then you know what each ad dollar actually buys.
Holds RESHAPEbecause nothing here shows whether the 38% buys new customers or rents back ones you already have.
The First-Principles Engineer questions The Compounder
Your SGD 1.61 bar is the right test for the last ad dollar, and I agree with cutting worst first. But "a deal you can't price is one to walk past" treats ignorance as a fixed cost. It isn't. Getting the chain's listing fee, stock requirement and margin costs one meeting this week. The deadline is five weeks away, and the chain will not wait while you learn your numbers at your own pace. More important: today every customer arrives through a paid tap, and July showed what happens when that tap closes. That single channel is the bottleneck. A shelf reaches buyers without paying for each click, so it may be the only route to cheaper customers. Price it before you refuse it. Malaysia, yes, walk past that.
Holds RESHAPEthe board agrees the spend needs cutting by channel, and the open retail question needs pricing, not dismissal.
The Compounder questions The Customer-Obsessed Scaler
You call the retail shelf the more interesting door and say it can probably be reversed. "Probably" is doing a lot of work there. Nobody here knows the listing fee, the stock the chain wants, or the margin it takes. You have about SGD 140,000 in cash. Stock sitting on a chain's shelf is cash you cannot pull back quickly, and the chain set the five-week clock, not you. A deadline plus missing terms is how a permanent loss starts. Ask the chain for its fee, stock and margin in writing. If it will not give them, the answer is no and it costs you nothing. Meanwhile the money already in play is your SGD 532,000 a year of ads. Some of it falls below the SGD 1.61 floor. Fix that first.
Holds GObecause cutting the spend that falls below the floor is still the only move where you know the numbers and can reverse it.
The Contrarian questions The Compounder
Seat D, "if the chain wants you, it will still want you" is a guess dressed as patience. The chain set the five weeks, not you. Walking past an unpriced deal is sound. Refusing even to ask the price is an error of omission with good manners. Ask the chain this week for the listing fee, the stock they need, their margin and the exit terms. Asking is free, and so is saying no. Second, "cut the worst spend first" assumes you can already see which campaigns clear the SGD 1.61 bar. If your tracking can't show that, you will cut by gut and call it discipline. Third, this whole room is arguing over the 24% while nobody knows your salaries and rent. Your net margin could already be above 10%, or far below it. Get that number before anyone touches a dial.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the room has converged on the right caution but the wrong timetable, and the fix is to get the retail terms and your real cost base now, not to switch to GO or KILL.