Fullerly

Fullerly Board · Customers

My biggest client wants 15% off

One saved meeting. The verdict and the plan come first; the full debate is underneath if you want to check the reasoning.

  • A saved meeting, corrected (listed below)
  • Simulated board
  • Schools of thought from the public record
  • Not advice

The decision

Our biggest client, 55% of revenue, wants a 15% price cut on next year's contract. Accept, refuse, or accept only with a volume guarantee?

RESHAPE

Reshape: do not accept a flat 15%. Counter privately at no more than 5% to 8%, tied to a written 12-month monthly volume floor. Start two cash-in moves and a costed fallback this week, and make the final hold or walk call only at the client's own 3-week deadline.

How the five seats voted

  • RESHAPEThe CustomerThe client's own cost of switching couriers is your real bargaining chip, and you have not tested it yet.
  • RESHAPEThe RivalA flat 15% on about SGD 1.76m is roughly SGD 264,000, more than your whole net profit of about SGD 192,000.
  • RESHAPEThe CounselOn your own figures, 15% of about SGD 1.76m is roughly SGD 264,000, more than your whole net profit of about SGD 192,000.
  • RESHAPEThe Go-to-Market OperatorA flat 15% on about SGD 1.76m is about SGD 264,000 a year, more than your whole net profit of about SGD 192,000.
  • RESHAPEThe Systems ScepticA flat 15% on about SGD 1.76m is roughly SGD 264,000 a year, more than your entire net profit of about SGD 192,000.

The plan

  1. This week · You

    30-day experiment: today, ask the client's decision maker in writing what drives the 15% and what monthly volume they would commit to for 12 months.

    Measure this client's direct cost per delivery from 3 months of records and set a private counter between 5% and 8%. Pass if, by their 3-week deadline, they confirm in writing a cut of 8% or less tied to a monthly volume floor.

  2. This week · You

    Raise cash and build the fallback: chase every overdue invoice across all clients, ask your bank about an overdraft or short-term facility of at least SGD 174,000 (about 3 weeks of costs), and draft a cost-cut list sized to losing this client (about SGD 147,000 a month of revenue).

  3. 2026-11-27 · You

    Pitch 4 e-commerce shops like the one that signed last year, aiming for 2 signed by the 2027-01-26 review, and write down what a typical new shop pays you a year.

Then decide this yourself

If this client left, which costs could you stop within 3 weeks, and could you get down to a cost base the other SGD 1.44m of revenue can carry?

GO backs one option as it stands, KILL means do nothing or stop, RESHAPE means go ahead only with a named change.

Fact-check corrections to this saved meeting: Corrected a monthly figure in action 2 (was SGD 130,000; the client is about SGD 147,000 a month of revenue).

In the app you make the final call in your own words; it goes into a decision journal with a 90-day review date.

Fullerly can do this next

Fullerly QuoteDesk Live

A WhatsApp enquiry becomes an itemised quotation from your own price list. Free, no sign-up, no AI. You check it and send it yourself.

A separate tool. Nothing from this meeting is sent to it.

See Fullerly QuoteDesk

Read the full meetingThe brief, five cases with their sources, the cross-examination and the Chair's reasoning

Step 1 · The decision brief

Our biggest client, 55% of revenue, wants a 15% price cut on next year's contract. Accept, refuse, or accept only with a volume guarantee?

The options

  • Accept the 15% cut; Refuse and risk losing them; Accept 15% only with a 12-month volume guarantee

Constraints

cash: about SGD 180,000, roughly 7 weeks of costs; time: they want an answer in 3 weeks; people: 35 delivery riders, 4 office staff

Step 2 · Opening round

Five seats vote and make their case.

Each seat argues independently: it votes GO, KILL or RESHAPE, makes its case, then puts one question to the owner and proposes a 30-day test.

The Customer

Composite stakeholder

RESHAPE

The client's own cost of switching couriers is your real bargaining chip, and you have not tested it yet.

For your client, leaving you is a risky switch, so the price ask is probably an opening position, not a cliff.

Sit in your client's chair. Asking for 15% costs them nothing; leaving costs them plenty. Moving all their deliveries to a new courier means new riders learning their customers, missed drops while it beds in, and someone in their office explaining that to their own boss. Nobody wants to be the guinea pig for a rival's onboarding. So the request is probably an opening position. Your own numbers say a full 15% on about SGD 1.76m is roughly SGD 264,000, more than the SGD 192,000 you net in a year. Option 1 hands them your profit. Option 3 as written asks for a guarantee they have never mentioned. Find out what they are comparing you to before you price anything, and have a qualified professional check any volume clause.

The question you must answer

After rider pay, fuel and vehicle costs, how much does each delivery for this client actually leave you?

The 30-day test

This week, the owner asks the client's decision maker two things: what is driving the 15%, and what monthly volume they would commit to for 12 months. In parallel, work out this client's cost per delivery from rider pay, fuel and vehicle records, and pitch new e-commerce shops, starting with the kind of shop that signed last year.

Within 30 days the client names a 12 month volume in writing and accepts a counter that keeps their deliveries above your direct cost, and at least one new shop signs. If the client will not name any volume, treat it as price shopping and hold your price.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Rival

Composite stakeholder

RESHAPE

A flat 15% on about SGD 1.76m is roughly SGD 264,000, more than your whole net profit of about SGD 192,000, so accepting blind could turn the business loss-making.

A client asking for exactly 15% usually has a rival's quote in hand, so the real question is whether that rival can actually match your service.

That 15% did not come from nowhere. Someone like me quoted it, probably bundled with something we already sell them. But I quoted it to win the account, not knowing your routes, your 35 riders' habits, or what this client's peak days really cost to serve. If I win at that price, I run it thin and hope to make it back on bundling. You hold the thing I lack: proven delivery on their volume. So do not simply answer the number. Find out what this client actually earns you per delivery, offer only what that can carry, and make them commit volume for it. Meanwhile, every week you stay at 55% is a week I know you will fold. Your negotiating position improves only as other clients grow.

The question you must answer

After rider pay, fuel and vehicle costs, how much does each delivery for this client actually leave you, and who quoted them the 15%?

The 30-day test

Starting Monday, take the last three months of this client's deliveries and match them against rider pay, fuel and vehicle costs to get contribution per delivery. In the same 30 days, pitch at least four e-commerce shops, twice last year's effort, using the one you signed as the reference.

Pass if the contribution margin on this client stays above zero after your counteroffer and at least one new shop signs. If even a smaller cut pushes this client below zero contribution, it is a loss-maker at that price, so refuse it and put all effort into replacing that revenue toward the 40% line. A qualified professional must check any guarantee wording before you sign anything.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Counsel

Composite stakeholder

RESHAPE

On your own figures, 15% of about SGD 1.76m is roughly SGD 264,000, more than your whole net profit of about SGD 192,000, so you cannot promise that cut in writing without knowing what the client promises back.

A price cut is a firm written promise from you, while a "volume guarantee" the client has never mentioned is, so far, a hope.

Notice the asymmetry. Your concession is precise: 15%, twelve months, in ink. Their side does not exist yet. A guarantee that says "expected volume" or "best efforts" is decoration. One with a named monthly floor and a stated consequence if they miss it is an obligation. Before you offer anything, read the contract you already have. Look for notice periods, exclusivity, and anything that limits taking on other clients, because a clause like that quietly kills your 40% goal. Then think about your 35 riders: if volume drops after you cut price, what have you committed to them? I would not sign the cut until a qualified professional has checked both documents. That is not caution for its own sake. It is knowing exactly what you are agreeing to.

The question you must answer

What does your current contract with this client say about notice, exclusivity and price changes, and who has actually read it this month?

The 30-day test

Starting Monday, pull the current client contract and list every term on price, notice, exclusivity and minimum volume. In parallel, take the last three months of rider pay, fuel and vehicle costs for this client's deliveries and divide by their delivery count to get direct cost per delivery.

The contract holds nothing that blocks new clients, and price per delivery after the 15% cut stays above measured direct cost per delivery. If either fails, counter with a smaller cut tied to a written volume floor, or stop.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Go-to-Market Operator

A school of thought, drawn from the public record of Jason Lemkin, Madhavan Ramanujam, Nick Mehta

RESHAPE

The question this school always asksWho pays, how much, and are they still paying next year?

A flat 15% on about SGD 1.76m is about SGD 264,000 a year, more than your whole net profit of about SGD 192,000, so you need a price that moves with what you get back.

A discount is a pricing structure, and a flat cut with no metric attached is an irreversible underprice that never rolls back at the next renewal.

The real question here is not whether to cut, but what the cut buys you. Right now the client is asking you to give up more than you earn in a year in exchange for nothing written down. Option 3 is closer, but it still grants the full 15% before you know whether a delivery at that price covers rider pay, fuel and vehicle. Price per delivery, with a committed monthly minimum at each tier, makes the client pay for their discount in volume, which you can plan riders around. The client asking for a cut is also a renewal warning, so start building the replacement pipeline now. One of two e-commerce shops signed last year. That is a conversion rate, not an anecdote. Run it at ten times the volume. My bias is that I read every business as a SaaS funnel, and a delivery fleet has rider capacity limits that software does not. That is exactly why you need the tiers to set volume floors.

The question you must answer

What does one delivery for this client cost you directly, and what do you charge for it? Any contract wording on volume commitments needs checking by a qualified lawyer before you send it.

The 30-day test

Monday, pull the last 3 months of this client's invoices and the rider pay, fuel and vehicle costs on their routes to get contribution per delivery. By day 14, send the tiered counter. In parallel, pitch 20 e-commerce shops.

The client signs tiered terms where the business stays profitable at the committed minimum, and at least 2 new shops sign. If either fails, stop and replan, because the 40% line needs non-client revenue to grow from about SGD 1.44m to well over SGD 2m within 18 months.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Systems Sceptic

A school of thought, drawn from the public record of Bill Gurley, Werner Vogels, Benedict Evans

RESHAPE

The question this school always asksDoes this survive scale, scrutiny and the next platform shift?

A flat 15% on about SGD 1.76m is roughly SGD 264,000 a year, more than your entire net profit of about SGD 192,000, so Options 1 and 3 as written trade a profitable business for a busy, loss-making one.

A volume guarantee only helps if each extra delivery earns money, and you do not yet know whether this client's deliveries do; more volume at a loss is a faster way to lose.

Not all revenue is worth the same, and this client's revenue is the least durable kind: concentrated, price-setting, and now asking for more than your whole profit. A volume guarantee sounds like protection, but nobody has named a volume, and you cannot say what one delivery for them costs you. Until you can, you are negotiating blind. Treat this client as a single point of failure: if they leave, more than half the business goes with them. So the job this month is two things. First, find the real cost to serve them, and offer only what that margin can carry, in return for a floor on volume and cheaper ways to deliver for them, such as fewer, batched drop windows. Second, start replacing them now. To reach 40%, everyone else together must grow from about SGD 1.44m to about SGD 2.64m a year.

The question you must answer

If this client walked on the day you sent your counter, how many weeks would your SGD 180,000 last, and what would you cut first? A qualified professional should check any contract terms, including how a volume commitment would be written.

The 30-day test

Starting Monday, pull four weeks of rider pay, fuel and vehicle costs for this client's deliveries, divide by their delivery count to get cost per delivery, and in parallel pitch e-commerce shops like the one that signed last year.

By day 21, you know this client's cost per delivery and your counter costs less than SGD 192,000 a year after any savings, keeping the business profitable; fail if you cannot produce that figure, and then do not accept any cut.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

Step 3 · Cross-examination

Each seat takes on another.

Each seat cross-examines another seat's case. Then each one says whether it holds or changes its vote. In this meeting, no seat changed its vote.

  1. The Customer questions The Rival

    Seat B, you are guessing at my reasons and then negotiating against the guess. You assume a rival quoted 15%. Maybe. Or maybe my own boss told me to cut every supplier by 15% this year, and you are one line on that list. Those need different answers. A rival quote means I must weigh moving my parcels to a stranger who has never run my peak days. A blanket budget cut means I may accept something other than price: batched drop windows, a longer contract, fewer extras. For me, switching couriers mid-season is a risk to my job, not just a line on an invoice. So before you price anything, ask me one question: what is behind the 15%? The answer tells you what the cut is really worth to me.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause the client's untested switching cost is still the lever, and finding the reason behind the 15% is how you test it.

  2. The Rival questions The Customer

    Seat A, you are betting on a switching cost I get paid to remove. If I want this client, I do not ask them to move everything on day one. I offer to take a slice of their deliveries, say one district or one product line, at a price that stings you. Now nobody in their office has to explain a failed changeover to their boss, because nothing failed. I run cleanly for a few months, and the slice grows. Their "cost of leaving" falls every week I am in the door. So treat the 15% as possibly an opening line, yes, but also as possibly a quote already in their inbox. The owner should assume I am already talking to them, price for that, and start the replacement pipeline this month rather than leaning on inertia.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause a split trial by a rival makes concentration more dangerous, which strengthens the case for a costed counter plus active diversification.

  3. The Counsel questions The Go-to-Market Operator

    Seat D, you call one signing out of two pitches a conversion rate. It is a sample of two. If you plan cash around it, the 7 weeks of costs in the bank will find that out first. My bigger worry is the tiered price with monthly minimums. It sounds tidy, but every tier is a written promise in both directions. What does the business owe if 35 riders cannot cover the top tier on a peak day? What happens when the client misses the floor, and who tracks it? A minimum nobody measures is decoration. A price schedule signed before you know your cost per delivery writes the blind guess into the contract for a year. Measure the cost to serve first, then draft tiers, and have a qualified professional check what each clause commits you to.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause the cut still exceeds your whole net profit and nothing the other seats raised changes what you would be promising blind.

  4. The Go-to-Market Operator questions The Customer

    You are treating switching cost as a chip in your pocket, and nobody has counted it. You assume the client fears onboarding pain, but you have no evidence on their side, only a story about their office politics. Seat B's point cuts against you: a rival may already have quoted, and perhaps priced in that pain. If you play hard on a guess and they walk, 55% of revenue leaves and you have about 7 weeks of cash. Switching cost is only leverage once it is proven value. So prove it: pull this client's on-time and failed-drop record, put it in front of them, and tie any price change to a volume floor. A discount for nothing never rolls back. A price that moves with committed volume can.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause nothing here shows a flat 15% can be carried by margin you have not yet measured.

  5. The Systems Sceptic questions The Go-to-Market Operator

    Seat D, one signing from two pitches is a sample of two, not a conversion rate. "Run it at ten times the volume" is a narrative without a number under it. Nobody here knows what those shops pay per delivery, what they cost to serve, or whether the hit rate holds at twenty pitches. Tiered per-delivery pricing has the same hole. You cannot set tiers until you know what a delivery costs in rider pay, fuel and vehicle, and the owner has told us they do not know. Build tiers now and you are guessing in a spreadsheet instead of in a meeting. With about seven weeks of cash, measure cost per delivery this week from rider and fuel records, then price. The pipeline matters, but it is an 18-month answer to a 3-week question.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause nothing raised changes the fact that a SGD 264,000 cut against SGD 192,000 profit cannot be priced until cost per delivery is measured.

Step 4 · The Chair's reasoning

On your own figures a flat 15% is about SGD 264,000 a year (15% of about SGD 1.76m), more than your whole net profit of about SGD 192,000, so accepting it blind turns a profitable business into a loss-making one. Refusing outright is just as dangerous with 55% of revenue and about 3 weeks of cash, so the only defensible move is a smaller, volume-backed counter backed by cash and cost plans you start now.

The vote

VoteOpeningAfter cross-examination
GO00
KILL00
RESHAPE55

Where they agree

  • A flat 15% (about SGD 264,000) exceeds your entire annual profit (about SGD 192,000), so Option 1 as written is off the table.
  • Measure this client's direct cost per delivery from rider pay, fuel and vehicle records before pricing any counter.
  • Start replacing this client's revenue now, because every month at 55% weakens your position.

The live split

You must choose whether to treat the 15% as an opening position and lean on the client's cost of switching, or assume a rival quote is already in their inbox and price defensively while replacing revenue faster.

Against your constraints: Your cash figure conflicts with your totals: about SGD 3.0m of yearly costs is about SGD 58,000 a week, so SGD 180,000 lasts about 3 weeks, not 7. Separately, the client's 3-week window runs past your 2026-10-30 decision date, so on that date you set your counter, not the final deal.

Bring your own decision

Fullerly Board is in private testing. Ask for early access and bring the decision on your desk.

Ask for early accessHow the Board works →

Each seat is a labelled simulation of a way of reasoning, drawn from the public record of several operators. No seat is any one person, and none of them took part. Real quotes appear only in the boxes marked "From the public record", attributed and dated, kept apart from the simulation. Fullerly Board is in private testing.

Not investment, legal, financial, tax or medical advice. No person whose public words appear is affiliated with Fullerly Board or has endorsed it. Fullerly Board is provided by Aye Bot Pte. Ltd. (UEN 202549226G), Singapore.