Each seat cross-examines another seat's case. Then each one says whether it holds or changes its vote. In this meeting, no seat changed its vote.
The Customer questions The Rival
Seat B, you are guessing at my reasons and then negotiating against the guess. You assume a rival quoted 15%. Maybe. Or maybe my own boss told me to cut every supplier by 15% this year, and you are one line on that list. Those need different answers. A rival quote means I must weigh moving my parcels to a stranger who has never run my peak days. A blanket budget cut means I may accept something other than price: batched drop windows, a longer contract, fewer extras. For me, switching couriers mid-season is a risk to my job, not just a line on an invoice. So before you price anything, ask me one question: what is behind the 15%? The answer tells you what the cut is really worth to me.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the client's untested switching cost is still the lever, and finding the reason behind the 15% is how you test it.
The Rival questions The Customer
Seat A, you are betting on a switching cost I get paid to remove. If I want this client, I do not ask them to move everything on day one. I offer to take a slice of their deliveries, say one district or one product line, at a price that stings you. Now nobody in their office has to explain a failed changeover to their boss, because nothing failed. I run cleanly for a few months, and the slice grows. Their "cost of leaving" falls every week I am in the door. So treat the 15% as possibly an opening line, yes, but also as possibly a quote already in their inbox. The owner should assume I am already talking to them, price for that, and start the replacement pipeline this month rather than leaning on inertia.
Holds RESHAPEbecause a split trial by a rival makes concentration more dangerous, which strengthens the case for a costed counter plus active diversification.
The Counsel questions The Go-to-Market Operator
Seat D, you call one signing out of two pitches a conversion rate. It is a sample of two. If you plan cash around it, the 7 weeks of costs in the bank will find that out first. My bigger worry is the tiered price with monthly minimums. It sounds tidy, but every tier is a written promise in both directions. What does the business owe if 35 riders cannot cover the top tier on a peak day? What happens when the client misses the floor, and who tracks it? A minimum nobody measures is decoration. A price schedule signed before you know your cost per delivery writes the blind guess into the contract for a year. Measure the cost to serve first, then draft tiers, and have a qualified professional check what each clause commits you to.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the cut still exceeds your whole net profit and nothing the other seats raised changes what you would be promising blind.
The Go-to-Market Operator questions The Customer
You are treating switching cost as a chip in your pocket, and nobody has counted it. You assume the client fears onboarding pain, but you have no evidence on their side, only a story about their office politics. Seat B's point cuts against you: a rival may already have quoted, and perhaps priced in that pain. If you play hard on a guess and they walk, 55% of revenue leaves and you have about 7 weeks of cash. Switching cost is only leverage once it is proven value. So prove it: pull this client's on-time and failed-drop record, put it in front of them, and tie any price change to a volume floor. A discount for nothing never rolls back. A price that moves with committed volume can.
Holds RESHAPEbecause nothing here shows a flat 15% can be carried by margin you have not yet measured.
The Systems Sceptic questions The Go-to-Market Operator
Seat D, one signing from two pitches is a sample of two, not a conversion rate. "Run it at ten times the volume" is a narrative without a number under it. Nobody here knows what those shops pay per delivery, what they cost to serve, or whether the hit rate holds at twenty pitches. Tiered per-delivery pricing has the same hole. You cannot set tiers until you know what a delivery costs in rider pay, fuel and vehicle, and the owner has told us they do not know. Build tiers now and you are guessing in a spreadsheet instead of in a meeting. With about seven weeks of cash, measure cost per delivery this week from rider and fuel records, then price. The pipeline matters, but it is an 18-month answer to a 3-week question.
Holds RESHAPEbecause nothing raised changes the fact that a SGD 264,000 cut against SGD 192,000 profit cannot be priced until cost per delivery is measured.