Fullerly

Fullerly Board · Partners and family

My partner wants out

One saved meeting. The verdict and the plan come first; the full debate is underneath if you want to check the reasoning.

  • A saved meeting, unedited
  • Simulated board
  • Schools of thought from the public record
  • Not advice

The decision

My co-owner wants to leave our two-outlet cafe and asks SGD 250,000 for her 50%. Do I buy her out, bring in a new partner, or sell the whole business?

RESHAPE

Do not accept SGD 250,000 as asked; reshape Option 1 into a buyout at a price inside the accountant's range on reviewed, salary-adjusted profit, with a repayment the cafe can carry and a cash reserve kept.

How the five seats voted

  • RESHAPEThe CounselYou cannot price half of something when the only person who fully knows what it owes is the one leaving.
  • RESHAPEThe CompounderHer ask values half the cafe at well above what the accountant's own multiple supports, and the loan would be repaid from profit that may already be paying both of you.
  • RESHAPEThe Institution BuilderHer ask values the whole cafe at SGD 500,000.
  • RESHAPEThe ContrarianEveryone will see that SGD 90,000 plus a SGD 200,000 loan covers SGD 250,000 and say yes, without noticing the price is well above the accountant's own range.
  • RESHAPEThe CustomerYour customers notice nothing if you keep the counter running.

The plan

  1. This week · You

    Start the 30-day test: book an independent accountant to restate profit after market salaries for both roles; ask the bank in writing for the rate and monthly repayment on SGD 160,000 and SGD 200,000 over 5 years; build with your co-owner a written list of every lease, loan, guarantee, supplier and staff contract, with signatory and end date, for both of you to sign

  2. 2026-11-20 · You

    With a qualified adviser, set the most you can pay: inside 1.5 to 2 times restated profit, halved, with yearly repayment at or under half of restated profit and one month of payroll and rent left in cash

  3. 2026-11-27 · You

    Have your adviser put a written offer to your co-owner based on the reviewed figures, and get her written response with terms before the decision date

Then decide this yourself

If the reviewed figures put her half well below SGD 250,000, will you still want to own and run both outlets alone, and is the friendship worth more to you than the gap in price?

GO backs one option as it stands, KILL means do nothing or stop, RESHAPE means go ahead only with a named change.

In the app you make the final call in your own words; it goes into a decision journal with a 90-day review date.

Read the full meetingThe brief, five cases with their sources, the cross-examination and the Chair's reasoning

Step 1 · The decision brief

My co-owner wants to leave our two-outlet cafe and asks SGD 250,000 for her 50%. Do I buy her out, bring in a new partner, or sell the whole business?

The options

  • Buy her out with a bank loan; Bring in a new partner for her half; Sell the whole cafe business

Constraints

cash: SGD 90,000 in savings I can use; time: she wants an answer in 2 months; people: 18 staff across two outlets, I run day to day, she does the books

Step 2 · Opening round

Five seats vote and make their case.

Each seat argues independently: it votes GO, KILL or RESHAPE, makes its case, then puts one question to the owner and proposes a 30-day test.

The Counsel

Composite stakeholder

RESHAPE

You cannot price half of something when the only person who fully knows what it owes is the one leaving.

The asset you are buying is not just two outlets and their profit; it is every lease, loan, guarantee, supplier contract and staff promise signed in either name, and a casual exit with no written agreement can leave some of those attached to the wrong person.

You have no written agreement, a profit figure nobody can say is after fair salaries, and a partner who keeps the books. That is three unknowns stacked on a quarter of a million dollars. As an estimate only: the accountant's 1.5 to 2 times SGD 160,000 values the whole business at SGD 240,000 to 320,000, so her half sits around SGD 120,000 to 160,000. If that profit is before fair pay for both of you, the real figure is lower still. Her ask of SGD 250,000 may simply reflect what she knows and you do not. So the first job is to make sure you both know the same things: every lease and its end date, every bank facility and who guaranteed it, every staff contract across the 18 people. A qualified lawyer, accountant and tax adviser must check the legal, financial and tax parts before you sign anything. Keep the friendship conversation separate from this paperwork; they are different decisions.

The question you must answer

Whose name is on the leases and the bank facilities for both outlets, and what did each of you personally promise to get them?

The 30-day test

Starting Monday, ask your co-owner to sit with you for one session a week to build a single written list of every lease, loan, guarantee, supplier contract, licence and staff contract, with whose name is on each and when it ends, and book an independent accountant to review the last two years of accounts and restate profit after a market salary for each of your two roles.

By day 30, every item on the list has a named signatory and an end date with zero unknowns, and the reviewed profit is in hand; if either is missing, do not agree a price, and push the timeline rather than guess.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Compounder

A school of thought, drawn from the public record of Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, Mark Leonard, John Malone

RESHAPE

The question this school always asksWhat is it worth, and what does it compound into over 20 years?

Her ask values half the cafe at well above what the accountant's own multiple supports, and the loan would be repaid from profit that may already be paying both of you.

The SGD 160,000 may be two owners' wages dressed up as profit, and multiples of an inflated number produce inflated prices.

Start with what it is worth. Using your numbers, this is an estimate: 1.5 to 2 times SGD 160,000 gives the whole cafe SGD 240,000 to 320,000, so half is SGD 120,000 to 160,000. Her SGD 250,000 is roughly three times her SGD 80,000 share of profit. Worse, if that SGD 160,000 is before paying either of you a fair salary, the true profit is lower and the fair range falls with it. The day she leaves, someone must be paid to do the books, and that cost comes straight out of the profit that services the loan. Repaying SGD 200,000 over five years is SGD 40,000 a year before any interest. Buying at the wrong price is how a good cafe becomes one you cannot afford. The friendship is the personal decision; the price is the business one. Keep them in separate conversations, and have a qualified professional check the loan, legal and tax side.

The question you must answer

What do you and she each take home from the cafe in a year now, salary plus payouts?

The 30-day test

This week, get a written monthly repayment figure from the bank for the loan, and price a part-time bookkeeper plus a market manager salary for your role, then recompute yearly profit after both.

Yearly loan repayments no more than half of that recomputed profit, or you do not buy at SGD 250,000 and counter inside the recomputed range.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Institution Builder

A school of thought, drawn from the public record of Satya Nadella, Indra Nooyi, Jamie Dimon, Stephen Schwarzman

RESHAPE

The question this school always asksDoes the organisation, the balance sheet and the culture survive this?

Her ask values the whole cafe at SGD 500,000. That is about 3.1 times profit, well above the accountant's range, and the profit itself may be overstated.

When she leaves, the books leave with her, so the profit you are buying has to carry a paid bookkeeper and a loan, not just your living.

Ask whether the institution survives the exit, not whether you can sign the cheque. Here is the estimate, with the working shown. At 1.5 to 2 times SGD 160,000, the whole business is worth SGD 240,000 to 320,000, so her half is roughly SGD 120,000 to 160,000. If that SGD 160,000 is before fair salaries, both numbers fall. She is asking SGD 250,000. The fortress balance sheet idea is simple: never take on so much that one bad month or one sick barista ends you. Keep the friendship conversation separate. That is the personal decision. The business decision is the number, and you should agree it on clean accounts, ideally reviewed by an independent accountant you both trust. A qualified professional must check the loan, the legal terms and any tax effects.

The question you must answer

Is the SGD 160,000 profit after paying you both a fair wage, and what do each of you take home today?

The 30-day test

Starting Monday, get three things in writing: the profit after a market salary for an operations manager and for a bookkeeper, the bank's actual monthly repayment, and a quote for outsourced bookkeeping. A free SME Centre diagnosis can help you frame the figures.

Go only if three things hold. The price for her half falls within 1.5 to 2 times the salary-adjusted profit, halved. The yearly loan repayment plus bookkeeping cost leaves profit you can live on. At least one full month of payroll for both outlets stays in cash. If any of these fails, renegotiate or move to Option 2.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Contrarian

A school of thought, drawn from the public record of Charlie Munger, Peter Thiel, Alex Karp, Kazuo Inamori

RESHAPE

The question this school always asksWhat is everyone here getting wrong?

Everyone will see that SGD 90,000 plus a SGD 200,000 loan covers SGD 250,000 and say yes, without noticing the price is well above the accountant's own range.

The person leaving is the only one who keeps the books, so you would be borrowing against a profit figure that only the seller fully understands.

Here is the working, labelled as a rough estimate. The accountant said 1.5 to 2 times profit. On SGD 160,000, that values the whole cafe at SGD 240,000 to 320,000, so her half is about SGD 120,000 to 160,000. Her ask of SGD 250,000 implies the whole cafe is worth SGD 500,000, roughly 3 times profit. And if that SGD 160,000 is before paying either of you a fair salary, the real number is lower still, because her leaving creates a bookkeeping cost that did not exist before. Invert it. The way this fails is a five year loan that only works on the old profit figure. Keep the friendship and the price separate. The friendship is personal. The price is business, and it should be based on numbers, not on goodwill.

The question you must answer

If the reviewed number values her half below SGD 250,000, are you willing to tell her so plainly, and will she accept a price set by the books?

The 30-day test

This week, have an independent accountant review the last two years of accounts, get a quote for a part-time bookkeeper, and ask the bank in writing for the rate and monthly repayment on SGD 160,000 and on SGD 200,000. The free SME Centre consultation is a cheap place to start. A qualified professional must check the financial, legal and tax side of any buyout.

Proceed only if reviewed yearly profit, after a fair salary for you and the bookkeeper's cost, covers 1.5 times the bank's quoted yearly repayment. If it does not, stop and renegotiate the price or look at selling.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

The Customer

Composite stakeholder

RESHAPE

Your customers notice nothing if you keep the counter running, but nobody, you included, should pay for a half whose real profit nobody can state.

Whoever pays for this half is a customer, you included, and customers do not pay full price for a fuzzy product sold by the person who keeps the books.

A new partner or a buyer will behave like every customer I know. They will compare this to doing nothing, ask what they get on day one, and walk at the first number nobody can explain. Right now the profit may still include both your salaries, there is no written agreement, and the person leaving is the one who does the books. The ask values the whole cafe at SGD 500,000, about three times profit. The accountant's 1.5 to 2 times gives SGD 240,000 to 320,000 for the whole, so an estimated SGD 120,000 to 160,000 for half, and lower once fair salaries come out. That is an estimate, not a price. Agreeing the facts is business. Agreeing the price kindly is friendship. Keep them in separate conversations. A qualified accountant and lawyer must check the financial, tax and legal parts.

The question you must answer

Once you take out a fair salary for what each of you actually does, what does the cafe really make in a year?

The 30-day test

From Monday, have the accountant restate last year's profit with a fair market salary deducted for the day to day role and for the books, and get the bank's written interest rate and monthly repayment for SGD 200,000 over 5 years.

Pass if the monthly repayment fits inside the salary-adjusted profit with room left for payroll in both outlets. If it does not, stop and take the reviewed figures back to your co-owner before considering a partner or a sale.

Simulated seat. The words above are generated and speak for no one named here.

Step 3 · Cross-examination

Each seat takes on another.

Each seat cross-examines another seat's case. Then each one says whether it holds or changes its vote. In this meeting, no seat changed its vote.

  1. The Counsel questions The Compounder

    You say start with what it is worth. I say start with what it owes, because you cannot value half of something until you know what it promised. Your arithmetic is tidy, but it assumes the SGD 160,000 is the whole story. The person leaving keeps the books. Who signed the leases for both outlets? Are there guarantees, supplier contracts, staff entitlements or tax filings in her name, or yours? If she walks out still attached to obligations, or you inherit ones nobody has listed, your SGD 120,000 to 160,000 range is guessing. Before any price talk, both of you should list every obligation, owner and paper trail, and have a qualified professional check the legal, tax and financial parts. Price follows the list, not the other way round.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause the room agrees the price is too high, but nobody has yet asked what the business has promised in writing, and that still comes first.

  2. The Compounder questions The Customer

    You say nobody should pay for a half whose real profit nobody can state. Agreed, but that is a reason to measure, not to stall. The facts can be found inside the two months. Pull what each of you actually took home, price a hired bookkeeper, and get the bank's repayment figure in writing. Your test asks what a buyer gets on day one. The better test asks what this owner keeps over twenty years. You run the counter, you know the 18 staff, and you know both sites. Selling or bringing in a stranger gives that up permanently, and nobody here has sized that loss. The price is too high on today's working, but the exit can still happen at the right number. Get the numbers checked by a qualified professional, then make a counter-offer. Silence is not a counter-offer.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause the price still sits above the accountant's own range on a profit figure that may include both salaries, and nothing in the debate changed that.

  3. The Institution Builder questions The Compounder

    Seat B is right that the price is too high, but stops at the price. A buyout at a fair figure can still sink you. Paying SGD 250,000 means the full SGD 200,000 loan plus SGD 50,000 of your savings, leaving SGD 40,000 against monthly payroll for 18 staff, rent on two outlets, and a new bookkeeping cost. One slow month and you are a forced seller of a business you just bought. The question is not only "what is half worth?" but "what is the most I can pay and still have a reserve?" Measure your monthly payroll and rent, decide how many months of cover you will keep in cash, and only negotiate with what is left. A qualified financial professional must check the loan terms before you agree to anything.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause a lower price fixes only half the risk; the other half is keeping a reserve, which still needs reshaping.

  4. The Contrarian questions The Compounder

    Seat B, you made the same move as every seat here, and that is the tell. You take the accountant's 1.5 to 2 times, then say fair salaries push it lower still. Ask the accountant which profit that multiple was meant for. If it was meant for profit before owner pay, you have cut the value twice. Your own arithmetic also undercuts your fear: SGD 40,000 a year of principal against SGD 160,000 of profit is not what sinks this cafe. What sinks it is the books walking out the door with the person who keeps them, and nothing written that stops her selling her half to a stranger. Her real price is set by her alternatives, not by your range. Find out what those alternatives are first, and have a qualified professional check the numbers.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause the room agreeing on a range does not make the range right, and the facts still need agreeing before any price.

  5. The Customer questions The Contrarian

    You inverted the price and stopped there. The cafe also fails if the profit figure is right but the till goes quiet. Eighteen staff, two outlets and the person who does the books walking out is exactly when regulars notice slower service and a new face at the counter. Your loan only works if they keep coming. And you treat the owner as the only buyer. A new partner or an outside buyer will ask my questions first: who pays for this already, what changes on day one, and who knows the numbers once she leaves. Without clean accounts and staff who have agreed to stay, Options 2 and 3 fetch less than the accountant's range, not more. So before anyone argues about SGD 250,000, get the books handed over and checked by a qualified professional.

    Holds RESHAPEbecause every seat agrees the price cannot be judged until someone can state the real profit after fair pay for both roles.

Step 4 · The Chair's reasoning

Every seat reached the same arithmetic. On the accountant's 1.5 to 2 times SGD 160,000, half the cafe is an estimated SGD 120,000 to 160,000, while her ask values the whole at SGD 500,000, about 3.1 times profit, on a figure nobody can say is after fair pay. The stronger point is not only that the price is high: after the person who does the books leaves, the cafe must carry a loan and a paid bookkeeper, and only reviewed figures, a written bank repayment and a complete list of obligations can show whether it can.

The vote

VoteOpeningAfter cross-examination
GO00
KILL00
RESHAPE55

Where they agree

  • Her ask of SGD 250,000 sits well above the accountant's own range, an estimated SGD 120,000 to 160,000 for half
  • Restate profit after a market salary for both roles and get the bank's written repayment before agreeing any price
  • The price is the business decision and the friendship is the personal one; keep them in separate conversations

The live split

You must choose whether to hold out for a fully reviewed price even if that strains her two-month window, or settle sooner on a figure you can afford with a larger reserve kept back.

Against your constraints: Paying SGD 250,000 means the full SGD 200,000 loan plus SGD 50,000 of your SGD 90,000, leaving SGD 40,000 against payroll for 18 staff and rent on two outlets, which strains your goal of a cafe you can afford.

Bring your own decision

Fullerly Board is in private testing. Ask for early access and bring the decision on your desk.

Ask for early accessHow the Board works →

Each seat is a labelled simulation of a way of reasoning, drawn from the public record of several operators. No seat is any one person, and none of them took part. Real quotes appear only in the boxes marked "From the public record", attributed and dated, kept apart from the simulation. Fullerly Board is in private testing.

Not investment, legal, financial, tax or medical advice. No person whose public words appear is affiliated with Fullerly Board or has endorsed it. Fullerly Board is provided by Aye Bot Pte. Ltd. (UEN 202549226G), Singapore.