Each seat cross-examines another seat's case. Then each one says whether it holds or changes its vote. In this meeting, no seat changed its vote.
The Counsel questions The Compounder
You say start with what it is worth. I say start with what it owes, because you cannot value half of something until you know what it promised. Your arithmetic is tidy, but it assumes the SGD 160,000 is the whole story. The person leaving keeps the books. Who signed the leases for both outlets? Are there guarantees, supplier contracts, staff entitlements or tax filings in her name, or yours? If she walks out still attached to obligations, or you inherit ones nobody has listed, your SGD 120,000 to 160,000 range is guessing. Before any price talk, both of you should list every obligation, owner and paper trail, and have a qualified professional check the legal, tax and financial parts. Price follows the list, not the other way round.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the room agrees the price is too high, but nobody has yet asked what the business has promised in writing, and that still comes first.
The Compounder questions The Customer
You say nobody should pay for a half whose real profit nobody can state. Agreed, but that is a reason to measure, not to stall. The facts can be found inside the two months. Pull what each of you actually took home, price a hired bookkeeper, and get the bank's repayment figure in writing. Your test asks what a buyer gets on day one. The better test asks what this owner keeps over twenty years. You run the counter, you know the 18 staff, and you know both sites. Selling or bringing in a stranger gives that up permanently, and nobody here has sized that loss. The price is too high on today's working, but the exit can still happen at the right number. Get the numbers checked by a qualified professional, then make a counter-offer. Silence is not a counter-offer.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the price still sits above the accountant's own range on a profit figure that may include both salaries, and nothing in the debate changed that.
The Institution Builder questions The Compounder
Seat B is right that the price is too high, but stops at the price. A buyout at a fair figure can still sink you. Paying SGD 250,000 means the full SGD 200,000 loan plus SGD 50,000 of your savings, leaving SGD 40,000 against monthly payroll for 18 staff, rent on two outlets, and a new bookkeeping cost. One slow month and you are a forced seller of a business you just bought. The question is not only "what is half worth?" but "what is the most I can pay and still have a reserve?" Measure your monthly payroll and rent, decide how many months of cover you will keep in cash, and only negotiate with what is left. A qualified financial professional must check the loan terms before you agree to anything.
Holds RESHAPEbecause a lower price fixes only half the risk; the other half is keeping a reserve, which still needs reshaping.
The Contrarian questions The Compounder
Seat B, you made the same move as every seat here, and that is the tell. You take the accountant's 1.5 to 2 times, then say fair salaries push it lower still. Ask the accountant which profit that multiple was meant for. If it was meant for profit before owner pay, you have cut the value twice. Your own arithmetic also undercuts your fear: SGD 40,000 a year of principal against SGD 160,000 of profit is not what sinks this cafe. What sinks it is the books walking out the door with the person who keeps them, and nothing written that stops her selling her half to a stranger. Her real price is set by her alternatives, not by your range. Find out what those alternatives are first, and have a qualified professional check the numbers.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the room agreeing on a range does not make the range right, and the facts still need agreeing before any price.
The Customer questions The Contrarian
You inverted the price and stopped there. The cafe also fails if the profit figure is right but the till goes quiet. Eighteen staff, two outlets and the person who does the books walking out is exactly when regulars notice slower service and a new face at the counter. Your loan only works if they keep coming. And you treat the owner as the only buyer. A new partner or an outside buyer will ask my questions first: who pays for this already, what changes on day one, and who knows the numbers once she leaves. Without clean accounts and staff who have agreed to stay, Options 2 and 3 fetch less than the accountant's range, not more. So before anyone argues about SGD 250,000, get the books handed over and checked by a qualified professional.
Holds RESHAPEbecause every seat agrees the price cannot be judged until someone can state the real profit after fair pay for both roles.