Each seat cross-examines another seat's case. Then each one says whether it holds or changes its vote. In this meeting, 1 of 5 seats changed their vote.
The Customer questions The Compounder
You call a price rise the cheapest test there is. Cheap for whom? Your test runs on your 120 regulars, and they are the success line. Your cushion of about 53 lost manicures a month is counted in manicures, not people. The owner does not know how often a regular comes in, so nobody can say how many regulars that is. It could be well past ten before anyone notices. From my chair, a regular sees the same chair, the same technician and a bigger bill, while two salons nearby are waving smaller ones. I do not need a reason to leave. I need a reason to stay, and you have not given one. Test strangers first. Tell regulars early, with a date, and they will mind far less.
Changed vote GO to RESHAPEbecause a rise for new customers now and regulars later on a stated date tests the price without spending the success line to find out.
The Rival questions The Customer
Seat A, your plan aims the S$55 at exactly the customers I am fishing for. You said yourself a newcomer is already shopping, and my discount banner is on the street they are walking down. You have put your highest price where my cut bites hardest and your lowest price where it barely reaches. That is backwards. Then you tell regulars their rate is held as thanks. The day one of them brings a friend who pays S$55, I get a free advert: same chair, same technician, two prices. And you do not know how many of the 260 manicures come from regulars, so you cannot say whether a newcomer-only rise moves profit at all. Charge everyone one price and let my cuts sort the bargain hunters from your regulars.
Holds GObecause nothing here closes the two-price gap I would exploit, and one price for everyone still survives my cuts best.
The Compounder questions The Customer
Seat A, your own story is the case against you. You say the regular never checks the price next door, because switching means a new technician and the risk of a bad set before a wedding. That is a switching cost, and a switching cost is pricing power. You have just described the customers least likely to leave over S$10, then proposed they pay nothing extra, with no end date. That is the See's Candies lesson run backwards. Meanwhile the newcomer, already comparing you with two discounters, pays the full rise. You have aimed the increase at the most price-sensitive buyer and exempted the least. And an open-ended thank-you rate becomes your real price within a year, just as the landlord asks for more. Raise everyone, explain it plainly, and count the regulars who actually leave.
Holds GObecause nothing argued here shows regulars are more price-sensitive than strangers, and the 90-day test only works if the rise reaches the customers who make up most of the visits.
The Go-to-Market Operator questions The Customer
You protect the regulars forever and call it thanks. A rate held with no end date is a discount, and discounts never roll back. Worse, you do not know how many of the 260 manicures come from regulars. If most do, Option 2 leaves most of your volume at S$45 and charges S$55 only to browsers standing outside two discount windows. That is the one group most likely to say no. You get little extra profit, a rent review in four months, and a loyal base that now expects the old price as a right. Your claim that regulars never compare prices is a guess, not a measurement. Test it: new customers pay S$55 now, and regulars get a written date when their rate moves. Count bookings every week until then.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the seats voting for one price still rest on a technician pay figure nobody has, and a dated two-step move tests the price before you bet every regular on it.
The Contrarian questions The Customer
Seat A, you argue against yourself. You say the regular never checks what next door charges, sits in the same chair, and fears a bad set before a wedding. That describes your least price-sensitive customer. Then you give that customer the discount and charge full price to the newcomer, the one person actually comparing windows. Ask how Option 2 fails. A regular brings a friend, the friend pays S$10 more for the same chair, and now both feel cheated. Meanwhile the whole room is quoting cushions that assume technicians are on a fixed wage, and nobody here knows that. Find the technician cost per manicure this week, before the rent review finds it for you. Then charge one price, say it plainly, and give regulars a warm note and a date, not a permanent exemption.
Holds GObecause nothing in the other seats' arguments shows that regulars are more price-sensitive than strangers, and that is the only thing that would justify a two-tier price.