Each seat cross-examines another seat's case. Then each one says whether it holds or changes its vote. In this meeting, no seat changed its vote.
The Customer questions The First-Principles Engineer
You say students feel only their tutor and their time slot, then your plan moves the time slot. Evening and weekend sessions at the other branch are a new timetable, and a new timetable is exactly what I would have to rebuild my week around. When you announce, I will not be thinking about wasted rent. I will ask three things. Who makes the extra 4 km trip? Does my child keep the same tutor on the same day? Is there a seat at my hour? If any answer is "we will see", I take Seat E's free trial. Before calling this a GO, ask every family which slot they need and whether they will follow, and get that commitment before the lease decision. Seat-hours on a plan are not seats my child sits in.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the merge still works only if the tutor and the slot travel together, and Seat B's plan breaks the slot.
The First-Principles Engineer questions The Institution Builder
You call the monthly loss, the fee per student and the spare seats "the decision," then ask for seven months to find them. Those are a day of work. The fee is on your invoices. Tutor pay is on your payroll. The spare seats at the branch 4 km away are on its timetable, slot by slot. Seven months of studying the problem is a comfortable cadence, and every one of those months costs SGD 9,500 in rent that teaches nobody. Your deadline is this quarter, not the lease end. Get the numbers this week, map each class to a free slot with the same tutor, collect paid deposits for next term, and give notice on the lease. Waiting is not neutral: the longer the rumour runs, the more time a rival has to make an offer to your 140 families.
Holds GObecause every seat agrees the value is the tutor and the time slot rather than the building, which supports deleting the building quickly.
The Institution Builder questions The First-Principles Engineer
You protect the weak branch's students and forget the healthy branch you are about to load them into. Nobody knows how many spare seats it has, slot by slot, yet you would send six tutors and a new evening and weekend timetable into it at once. That is how a merge turns one problem into two: crowded rooms, tutors arguing over slots, and current students at the receiving branch wondering why their centre got worse. The institution that must survive this is the one still standing after the lease ends. So measure the receiving branch's free seats per time slot first, collect paid deposits from movers second, and only then decide how many of the six tutors move and which hours open. Check the lease notice period too, because the clock may be shorter than seven months.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the case still rests on keeping the students and tutors while dropping the rent, and Seat B's error is in sequencing, not direction.
The Systems Sceptic questions The Rival
You say keep the same tutor, class and hour, and nothing changes. That only works if the branch 4 km away has free rooms at those exact hours, and you do not know its spare seats. Popular slots fill first everywhere, so the hours your students want are probably the hours already taken there. Then the merge breaks the tutor and time link you say is everything. Check the blast radius too. Move 140 students and 6 tutors into a branch of unknown size, and a crowded healthy branch starts losing its own students. One weak branch becomes two shaky ones. Before any announcement, map free room-hours at the receiving branch slot by slot against the weak branch's timetable. Then take paid deposits. Merge the slots that fit and let the rest go with the lease.
Holds GObecause Seat E's own logic supports exiting the lease, and my objection is to the untested merge mechanics, not to leaving.
The Rival questions The First-Principles Engineer
You say keep the students and the 6 tutors and delete the building. Good plan, if I were asleep. The day you announce the branch is closing, I am on the phone to those 6 tutors. Their students follow them, not your logo, so I do not need to poach 140 families. I only need to hire 6 people and open the same slots near the old address. Your plan treats the tutors as luggage you can ship 4 km. They are free agents with a following. Adding evening and weekend slots at the other branch also asks them to give up the hours that suit them, which makes my offer easier. Before anything goes public, lock in the tutors, keep their time slots, and collect paid deposits. Otherwise you have closed a branch and handed me its customers.
Holds RESHAPEbecause the case against the fix is strong but a careless merge simply moves the revenue to me.